BY
DARRELL HALEN
Facing a fellow sixthgrader,
Kristen Tornquist
shared her review
of the Cynthia Lord
novel, “Rules.”
After she finished and
heard Jordan Sayeedi, who
faced her, give his review of
a book he read, she moved to
another chair to pair with another
student and share book
reviews with him.
Kristen, 12, would eventually
sit across a table from
four other students, exchanging
book reviews with each
one. She was one of nearly 50
sixth-graders who gathered
on Tuesday, March 18, in the
Windham Middle School’s
media center to share what
media specialist Diana Greenleaf
called “rapid reviews.”
Modeled on “speed dating”
– in which people rotate
to meet each other over short
periods of time – this unique
book review exercise allowed
each student to hear a half-dozen
book reviews during
the 90-minute session.
Teacher Karen Rogers liked
the format because it allowed
her students to learn about other
books by interacting with
their peers. Unlike a traditional
book review that required
standing in front of a class, the
students were much more at
ease by meeting one-on-one.
“I think this was much more
effective,” Rogers said when the
session was done. “I think it
kept their interest longer.”
The students who participated
in the rapid reviews
– Rogers’ students and the
students in teacher Sue Guelli’s
class – each had read a
novel that is a contender for
the Great Stone Face Book
Award.
The award, sponsored by
the Children’s Librarians of
New Hampshire, is given annually
to the author whose
book receives the most votes
from fourth-, fifth-, and sixthgraders
in the state.
Nominees are chosen by a
committee, and votes are cast
by students during National
Library Week in April.
“This is an attempt by you
to become more informed voters,”
Rogers told the students
before they began sharing
their reviews. “The more informed
you make yourselves,
the more responsible your
vote becomes.”
During each of the six
rounds, each student had three-and-
a-half minutes to share his
or her review with the person
sitting across from them.
They discussed whether or
not they would recommend
the book for the Great Stone
Face Award – and why.
After each student heard a
review, they asked their partner
a question about the novel,
jotted down their opinion
of the book and rated it.
“Rules,” the book Kristen
read and liked, is about a 12-
year-old girl, Catherine, who
is frustrated with having an
autistic brother and longs for a
normal life.
The book Jordan read, “A
Drowned Maiden’s Hair,” by
Laura Amy Schlitz, tells the
story of a girl who is adopted
by three spinsters who reveal
to her the role she will play in
their séances.
“I will definitely cast a vote
for this book,” Jordan shared
in his review. “The book was
exciting and suspenseful.”